Orkney is voted the best Scottish island followed by Shetland and Harris in a ranking by Which? 

10 mins read


Orkney, with its Neolithic sites and panoramic views, has been named the best Scottish island in a survey by Which?

While Scotland’s waters are home to approximately 800 islands, Which? Travel readers rated 14, highlighting how undiscovered and uninhabited many of them still are. And of the 14 that received enough visitors to be ranked in the survey, 10 received an impressive visitor score of 80 per cent or more.

Top-ranked Orkney – with its 70 or so islands off the country’s northeastern coast – was awarded an overall customer experience score of 88 per cent by visitors.

Orkney has been named the best Scottish island in a survey by Which? with a customer experience score of 88 per cent. Pictured is the island's Neolithic settlement of Skara Brae

Orkney has been named the best Scottish island in a survey by Which? with a customer experience score of 88 per cent. Pictured is the island’s Neolithic settlement of Skara Brae

Second-place Shetland received an overall score of 86 per cent. It received four stars for scenery, tourist attractions and shopping. Pictured is the archipelago's St Ninian's Beach

Second-place Shetland received an overall score of 86 per cent. It received four stars for scenery, tourist attractions and shopping. Pictured is the archipelago’s St Ninian’s Beach 

Harris, which came joint third, received five stars for both its beaches and its scenery, as well as for peace and quiet. Pictured is its spectacular Luskentyre beach

Harris, which came joint third, received five stars for both its beaches and its scenery, as well as for peace and quiet. Pictured is its spectacular Luskentyre beach 

A table showing the full ranking by Which?. Ten of the 14 islands surveyed were awarded customer scores of more than 80 per cent

A table showing the full ranking by Which?. Ten of the 14 islands surveyed were awarded customer scores of more than 80 per cent

Which? said it was the only destination in the survey to receive five stars for its tourist attractions, with visitors speaking highly of its many prehistoric sites and archaeology.

According to the consumer champion, some of the most frequently cited highlights included the Italian Church, Skara Brae, and the ‘spectacular’ Ring of Brodgar.

The archipelago was also praised for its ‘beautiful scenery and friendly locals’ said Which?, while others cited its remoteness as its main attraction. One reader told the consumer group they were particularly impressed by the ‘miles and miles of secluded sandy beaches with no-one in sight’.

In second place was Shetland, with a score of 86 per cent. Of its 100 or so islands, only 16 are inhabited and Which? believes this could go some way to explaining its five-star rating for peace and quiet.

It added: ‘This, combined with the fact it is closer to the Arctic Circle than it is to London, might lead some to think it could be difficult to reach – but the island was given four stars for ease of travel.’

It also received four stars for scenery, tourist attractions and shopping, meaning most travellers will be well catered to, Which? added.

Port Charlotte on Islay, which was joint third in the ranking with a score of 85 per cent.  The island received five stars for peace and quiet and four stars for its food and drink

Port Charlotte on Islay, which was joint third in the ranking with a score of 85 per cent.  The island received five stars for peace and quiet and four stars for its food and drink

The colourful houses of Tobermory on Mull. The island, which was joint third, scored five stars for its scenery

The colourful houses of Tobermory on Mull. The island, which was joint third, scored five stars for its scenery  

The Isle of Arran, pictured, received an overall customer score of 83 per cent. It scored a maximum of five stars for its scenery

The Isle of Arran, pictured, received an overall customer score of 83 per cent. It scored a maximum of five stars for its scenery 

Barra, pictured, scored five stars for both its beaches and peace and quiet. It gained an overall customer score of 83 per cent

Barra, pictured, scored five stars for both its beaches and peace and quiet. It gained an overall customer score of 83 per cent

Harris, Islay and Mull each received a visitor score of 85 per cent, putting them in joint third place.

Harris received five stars for both its beaches and its scenery, as well as for peace and quiet, making it ‘the perfect destination for anyone looking to escape to the great outdoors’.

Which? suggested: ‘Visitors can also head to Tarbert where they can buy their own Harris tweed, handwoven from local wool and reflecting the colours of the landscape, for a memento to remember the stunning views by.’

Islay, known for its distillery tours and whisky tasting, also received five stars for peace and quiet, as well as four stars for its food and drink. With fishing a mainstay of the island, Which? said visitors can enjoy ‘fresh seafood or fish and chips from many of the island’s restaurants’.

Lewis, pictured, in the Outer Hebrides, scored a maximum of five stars for its peace and quiet as well as four stars for its beaches, accommodation, ease of travel and value for money. Its overall score was 82 per cent

Lewis, pictured, in the Outer Hebrides, scored a maximum of five stars for its peace and quiet as well as four stars for its beaches, accommodation, ease of travel and value for money. Its overall score was 82 per cent

A stunning view across Quiraing - a landslip on the Isle of Skye. The island received an overall customer score of 82 per cent and five stars for its scenery

A stunning view across Quiraing – a landslip on the Isle of Skye. The island received an overall customer score of 82 per cent and five stars for its scenery

Iona, pictured, received an overall customer score of 80 per cent. It scored four stars for its beaches and tourist attractions

Iona, pictured, received an overall customer score of 80 per cent. It scored four stars for its beaches and tourist attractions 

While Mull only scored three stars for tourist attractions, food and drink, and shopping, its main attraction was its five-star scenery, made up of ‘white-sand bays fringed with wildflower-rich grassland, and pink granite skerries scattered across the sea’.

Which? explained: ‘Visitors can soak up the view from the top of Ben More, Mull’s only Munro, head to Tobermory with its picturesque painted houses, or visit one of the island’s imposing castles.’

Only one island in the survey – Benbecula – received a score that dipped below 70 per cent and Which? said this is ‘largely down to it being seen as a stepping stone between North and South Uist’.

It received a visitor score of 67 per cent but still received four stars for its beaches and peace and quiet.

While it only received three stars for scenery, visitors still spoke warmly of its landscape, with its wildlife and birdwatching being praised by a number of those in the survey, said the consumer champion.

Many of Scotland’s islands, including Orkney, are currently under Level 1 coronavirus restrictions. This means visitors can freely travel to the islands unless they are in a Level 3 area in Scotland, or under other tiered restrictions across the rest of the UK.

North Uist, pictured, in the Outer Hebrides, was awarded an overall customer score of 76 per cent. It received five stars for its peace and quiet

North Uist, pictured, in the Outer Hebrides, was awarded an overall customer score of 76 per cent. It received five stars for its peace and quiet 

South Uist, pictured, scored five stars for its beaches and peace and quiet. It had an overall score of 76 per cent

South Uist, pictured, scored five stars for its beaches and peace and quiet. It had an overall score of 76 per cent

Port Bannatyne on Bute, which received a customer score of 73 per cent. It got four stars for ease of travel and accommodation

Port Bannatyne on Bute, which received a customer score of 73 per cent. It got four stars for ease of travel and accommodation

Benbecula, pictured, received a visitor score of 67 per cent but still earned four stars for its beaches, and peace and quiet

Benbecula, pictured, received a visitor score of 67 per cent but still earned four stars for its beaches, and peace and quiet

Which? explained: ‘Almost all hospitality, shopping, visitor attractions and holiday accommodation are allowed to open and operate under Level 1 restrictions.

‘However, anyone planning to visit one of the islands should check the restrictions in place at the time they are due to travel, and only book with a provider that will allow them to rebook or cancel for a refund if they cannot travel as a result of government restrictions.

‘The Scottish government is also encouraging anyone planning on travelling to one of Scotland’s islands to take a coronavirus test before they do to reduce the risk of the virus being brought into island communities. Visitors are recommended to get tested three days before travelling and then again on the day of departure.’

Rory Boland, Which? Travel Editor, said: ‘After more than a year of restrictions that have seen most of us confined to our homes, many of us will be craving a holiday featuring beautiful scenery, grand landscapes, and the peace and quiet to soak it all in.

‘The Scottish islands have all of this in abundance, making many of them a brilliant choice for a UK holiday this summer.

‘You’ll need to pack for all seasons, and be prepared for a bit of travelling to get there – but when you do, you’ll be glad you made the effort.

‘Just be sure to book with an accommodation provider that will allow you to freely change or cancel your booking at short notice, should coronavirus restrictions change and prevent you from travelling as planned.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest from Blog